China Using AI To Correct Court Rulings Forcing Judges To Submit A Written Explanation To The Machine If They Disagree

Since at least 2016, China has been creating a “smart court” system, intending to improve the “fairness, efficiency, and credibility” of its judges. Now, China is using AI to correct court rulings forcing judges to submit a written explanation to the machine if they disagree.

China Using AI To Correct Court Rulings Forcing Judges To Submit A Written Explanation To The Machine If They Disagree

By suggesting laws, drafting documents, and alerting judges to “perceived human errors” in verdicts, China is employing artificial intelligence to “improve” its judicial system.

In a report on the system released this week, Beijing’s Supreme Court stated that judges must now formally consult the AI on every case, and if they choose to deviate from its decision, they must provide a written justification.

Additionally, the AI has been given access to police databases and China’s Orwellian social credit system, giving it the authority to penalize individuals, including by immediately listing a thief’s property for sale online.

Beijing has praised the new technology for “a significant contribution to the judicial advancement of human civilisation,” but critics claim it runs the risk of ushering in a time when machines govern the planet.

[jetpack_subscription_form title="Subscribe to GreatGameIndia" subscribe_text="Enter your email address to subscribe to GGI and receive notifications of new posts by email."]

Since Chief Justice Qiang Zhou called for the use of technology to enhance the “fairness, efficiency, and credibility” of the legal system at least as far back as 2016, China has begun constructing a “smart court” system.

This required installing robotic receptionists in courthouses to provide online legal assistance, automatic voice recognition recorders in courtrooms to do away with transcription needs, and “virtual courtrooms” where cases could be heard online.

A highly specialized “internet court” that only handles cases involving the virtual world, like online loans, domain name disputes, and copyright issues, has even been established in China.

It has resulted in the development of sizable databases into which data on every case is uploaded at a rate of approximately 100,000 per day.

In order to learn from these cases and then generate judgments and suggestions for new laws based on what it discovers, artificial intelligence has now been integrated into such databases.

China Using AI To Correct Court Rulings Forcing Judges To Submit A Written Explanation To The Machine If They Disagree 2
Beijing claims the system will hasten justice, but some claim it might lead to a society where machines govern. (Image File)

This implies the AI is now making choices on behalf of judges who must explain themselves if they want to override it instead of just gathering facts.

The South China Morning Post says that an AI prosecutor has even begun charging individuals in Shanghai with crimes it thinks they are responsible for.

Additionally, by integrating the AI with China’s social credit system, it will be able to punish offenders, such as preventing them from buying train or airline tickets if they refuse to pay a fine.

Professor of law at the China University of Political Science and Law, Zhang Linghan, cautioned that the rapid development of AI raises the possibility of a future in which machines reign over people.

In a document that was recently posted online, she asserted that “humans will gradually lose free will with an increasing dependency on technology.”

She continued, “we must be alert to the erosion of judicial power by technology companies and capital.”

GreatGameIndia is being actively targeted by powerful forces who do not wish us to survive. Your contribution, however small help us keep afloat. We accept voluntary payment for the content available for free on this website via UPI, PayPal and Bitcoin.

Support GreatGameIndia


  1. I have always said, for many years now, that the ultimate form of modern power hegemonies will include AI management systems that are well-controlled so as to maximize the use of collected data from people and institutions and make more “user friendly” to the ruling class of the various levers of pre-existing power structures that they already control. It is no surprise whatsoever that China is doing, or even that it HAS been doing it without any public admission. This is more of a public surfacing of such covertly already-deployed AI augmentation to social control (here applied to the judiciary).

Leave a Reply